Wednesday, September 10, 2008

Nature vs. Nurture

My Sweetie has been sick since Sunday/ maybe Saturday.
She has some kind of stomach bug and I LOVE IT!
She is so snugglely.
Don't get me wrong - I hate the extra laundry.
It is just I miss my baby and her illness gives me part of that back.
Her Behavior Normally:
She is 18 months now, mobile as a monkey and FREE as a BIRD! She loves to walk toward any kind of action. She sees kids playing on the swings - she is off. She sees a dog - Sweetie is off and running. She sees another adult, she is off. She isn't playing a game like keep away or peek a boo. She really likes going where the action is. Honest.

Sweetie is my most independent child - and that is saying a lot after having RHM. Really.

Her independence even translated to her first nursery class 2 weeks ago. She walked in and never looked back. The funny part was - an hour into the class I went into her nursery to borrow some crayons, Sweetie saw me and started crying. It was just weird. Sweetie does cry now and then, BUT - not to see her Mama. Her behavior made me laugh on the inside. I grabbed the crayons and left, knowing that the nursery workers could handle it. (I will get back to why I told that story.)



Her behavior during this stomach bug -
Her body is making her slow down during this illness. It's kinda nice. She sits still. She lets me hold her. She lets me read her half of a book (normally I can't get through 2 pages). She will stay in the stroller - WOW!
She even fell asleep ON ME and she hasn't done that in months (she isn't old enough to say "years" yet).
It makes me miss the baby that I had and realize that my little girl is growing up.
**Update:
She actually showed signs of getting better tonight, but we thought that Tuesday night - THEN we had to change her sheets around 2 AM. POOR BABY!

Sweetie and RHM's shoes - yes she is like most toddlers. She has a shoe fetish. Ask people at church. She will take your shoes off your feet and walk in your shoes. I think it is adorable, but I sure some think "Where is that girl's mother and why isn't she watching her?" Truth is I am watching her, but she provides me free entertainment.

Enough about me and my Sweetie - here is the question:
Do you think kids are born independent or do you think kids are raised independent? Do you think some kids are born clingy or are they raised that way? Do you think clingy kids NEED their parents or do clingy kids have parents that need to be NEEDED?
You know the clingy type. Think about how a different mom would have responded to her child crying in the nursery. (BTW Sweetie stopped crying as soon as I left. And the only bad report I got about Sweetie's first day in nursery was that she didn't like to share. Well, duh!) You can probably already guess how I feel about clingy vs independence, but I want to hear from you.



Nature VS. Nurture. Really simple. Give me your thoughts.

5 comments:

Petie said...

I honestly think it's a little bit of both. I think a child is born with their own distinct personality (clingy or not) but then it is reinforced by their parents/surroundings in which they grew up with (needy parents who need reinforcement of love or ones that give love and support independence). For your kids, I think they know you love them unfailingly and will support them no matter what they do. And that they need to find their own individual path in this world. They are just starting young. :)

Pam said...

I agree with Chrissy. Kids come with personality to start with but they receive reinforcement that brings out more traits and they develop patterns of behavior based on how the people around them react. I certainly believe some individuals start out as independent spirits and how they are nurtured affects how much of that they retain. I definitely believe that some kids are taught to be clingy/needy because they are rewarded for it.

da mmm said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
da mmm said...

I too agree with Chrissy. The way children are raised makes a difference. If they are smothered or if they are encouraged to explore and learn will become part of their character as an adult. Some children need more supervision for their own safety. Some parents need supervision too! Children learn what they see and hear.

Amanda said...

I agree with Chrissy too, Alex was independent from the time he was born, never let me rock him to sleep, Jedrek was my cuddle bug, and Corben is right in the middle. He is a bit of both. Every child has a personality and its how we raise them on how they develop that independance.